Oyster Bay has a great mix of antique shops and malls. We list 13 local antique stores in Oyster Bay, NY with phone numbers and websites so you can find the right store. Businesses covered in Oyster Bay include Greats Of The Game Collectibles, 1st Source Consignment and Syosset Fix-It Shop. Between them they cover antique store, antique mall, collectibles and consignment. Oyster Bay sits in Nassau County, New York. Nearby New York towns with listings include New York, Hempstead and Palmyra.
Have antiques or a full estate to sell in Oyster Bay? Tell us what you have and we'll connect you with local dealers and appraisers.
We currently track 13 antique shops, malls, and dealers serving Oyster Bay, NY in Nassau County.
Antique prices in Oyster Bay swing widely — small collectibles run $10-$100, quality vintage furniture $150-$1,500+, and rare pieces far more. Condition, provenance, and demand set the price more than age alone.
Many Oyster Bay listings also carry furniture, vintage collectibles, and jewelry, and often offer appraisals and estate buys.
Prices swing widely. Small collectibles run $10 to $100, quality vintage furniture $150 to $1,500 or more, and rare pieces far higher. Condition, provenance, and demand matter more than age alone.
Look at construction, materials, wear, and maker's marks, and ask the dealer directly. Reputable Oyster Bay shops will tell you whether a piece is restored or a reproduction and put it in writing.
Many do. They buy estates and single pieces and offer appraisals. If you are selling, call ahead and bring photos or the item.
An antique mall houses many independent dealers under one roof, which is great for browsing selection, while a shop is a single curated dealer. Oyster Bay has both.
Shops and malls in the Oyster Bay area carry a mix of vintage furniture, glassware, jewelry, coins, mid-century pieces, primitives, and estate collectibles. Call ahead — inventory turns over quickly and hours vary by season.
A single-owner shop reflects one dealer's taste and specialty, while an antique mall houses dozens of independent booths under one roof — more variety in one stop. Oyster Bay listings above include both.
Many Oyster Bay dealers buy as well as sell — individual pieces, collections, or whole estates. Call the store first to ask what they're buying and whether they do house calls or appraisals.
Vintage FurnitureCollectiblesEstate SalesConsignmentArchitectural SalvageFlea Markets
Get featured at the top of this page → Claim your listing, add photos, and appear above other stores.
Handy links for Oyster Bay and the surrounding area.